The History of the New York Islanders

by Gary J. Broome on June 01, 2023

The History of the New York Islanders

The New York Islanders, a professional ice hockey team based in New York, have a rich and storied history in the National Hockey League (NHL). Since their formation in 1972, the Islanders have left an indelible mark on the sport, achieving unparalleled success during the early 1980s and captivating fans with their exciting brand of hockey. This article delves into the fascinating journey of the New York Islanders, tracing their origins, examining their dynasty years, exploring their post-dynasty era, discussing the turbulent years, analyzing the millennial years, and providing insight into recent years and the future outlook. 

The Early Years (1972-1979)

Expansion into the National Hockey League (NHL):

In 1972, the NHL expanded its roster of teams by adding the New York Islanders and the Atlanta Flames. The decision to grant a franchise to Long Island was driven by the desire to tap into the growing popularity of hockey in the New York metropolitan area and to provide a local team for passionate fans.

The NHL's expansion was met with excitement and anticipation as the Islanders became the first central professional sports team to represent Long Island. The franchise's arrival marked a significant milestone for the region and its burgeoning sports culture.


Building the Foundation: The Front Office and Coaching Staff:


The Islanders assembled a robust front office and coaching staff to lay a solid foundation for success. The team's ownership group, led by Roy Boe, appointed Bill Torrey as the general manager. Torrey, known for his astute scouting and management skills, was pivotal in shaping the team's roster and direction.


Under Torrey's guidance, the Islanders named Phil Goyette as their first head coach. Goyette, a former NHL player, brought his experience and leadership to the young franchise. However, Goyette's tenure was short-lived, and Al Arbour would soon take the reins as head coach, leading the Islanders to their most significant achievements.

Inaugural Season and Early Struggles:


The Islanders' inaugural season in 1972-1973 was challenging, as expected for an expansion team. They finished with a record of 12 wins, 60 losses, and six ties, tallying just 30 points. Despite the difficulties, the team showcased glimpses of potential, and several young players displayed promising talent.


The Islanders struggled to find consistency and compete against more established NHL teams. However, the early years were crucial in building team chemistry, developing young players, and laying the groundwork for future success.

Rise to Prominence: The Islanders' First Playoff Berth:


After enduring several seasons of building and development, the Islanders achieved their first taste of success by clinching a playoff berth in the 1974-1975 season. Guided by Al Arbour, the team displayed resilience and determination, finishing with a record of 33 wins, 25 losses, and 22 ties.


In the playoffs, the Islanders faced the highly regarded New York Rangers in a thrilling first-round series. Despite falling short in the series, the Islanders' playoff appearance signaled their emergence as a competitive team in the NHL. The experience gained in this playoff run would prove invaluable in the coming years.


Sources:

  1. NHL.com. (n.d.). New York Islanders. Retrieved from https://www.nhl.com/islanders/

  2. Fitzpatrick, J. (2016, February 23). Reliving Islanders' first NHL win 44 years later. Retrieved from https://nypost.com/2016/02/23/reliving-islanders-first-nhl-win-44-years-later/

  3. Pagnotta, C. (2019, March 11). Islanders Build for the Future. Retrieved from https://thehockeywriters.com/new-york-islanders-history-build-for-future/

  4. NY Sports Day. (2022, May 25). This Date in Islanders History is May 25, 1973. Retrieved

Dynasty Years (1980-1983)

The Arrival of Al Arbour as Head Coach:


The foundation of the Islanders' dynasty was laid with the appointment of Al Arbour as head coach in 1973. Arbour, a former NHL player, and respected coach, instilled discipline, structure, and a winning culture within the team. Under his guidance, the Islanders transformed into a dominant force in the league.


Arbour's leadership and ability to bring out the best in his players played a crucial role in the team's success during the dynasty years. His strategic insight and tactical adjustments proved instrumental in playoff battles, earning him immense respect from players and peers.

Drafting Hall of Fame Players: Denis Potvin, Mike Bossy, Bryan Trottier, and more:


The Islanders' dynasty was fueled by exceptional talent acquired through the NHL Draft. The team's management, led by general manager Bill Torrey, made shrewd selections that formed the core of their championship-winning roster.


In 1973, the Islanders selected defenseman Denis Potvin with the first overall pick, establishing a defensive pillar and future Hall of Famer. Potvin's offensive prowess and his defensive skills played a significant role in the team's success.


The draft class 1977 proved pivotal as the Islanders selected forward Mike Bossy with the 15th overall pick. Bossy's natural scoring ability and hockey IQ made him one of the most prolific goal-scorers in NHL history. Alongside Bossy, the Islanders drafted Bryan Trottier, another Hall of Famer, who became the team's dynamic center and leader.

The Birth of a Dynasty: Four Consecutive Stanley Cup Championships:


From 1980 to 1983, the Islanders cemented their place as one of the greatest dynasties in NHL history. They captured an unprecedented four consecutive Stanley Cup championships, an achievement unmatched since the Montreal Canadiens of the late 1950s.


The Islanders' championship run began in the 1979-1980 season, defeating the Philadelphia Flyers in the Stanley Cup Final. This victory marked the first time they lifted the prestigious trophy in franchise history.


The subsequent three seasons witnessed the Islanders' dominance as they triumphed over formidable opponents, including the Vancouver Canucks, the Edmonton Oilers, and the Minnesota North Stars. Their cohesive play, offensive firepower, and outstanding goaltending, led by Billy Smith, propelled the team to unparalleled success.

The Islanders' Dominant Lineup and Key Players:


The Islanders' dynasty was built on a balanced, talented lineup showcasing exceptional skill and versatility. Beyond the star power of Potvin, Bossy, and Trottier, the team boasted a deep roster of impact players.


Goaltender Billy Smith provided a stalwart presence between the pipes, earning the nickname "Battlin' Billy" for his competitive spirit and clutch performances. Clark Gillies, a formidable power forward, combined physicality with offensive contributions, while Butch Goring excelled as a two-way forward and a reliable penalty killer.


The Islanders' success was further bolstered by role players such as Bob Nystrom, John Tonelli, and Duane Sutter, who consistently stepped up in critical moments and played crucial roles in securing championships.

Post-Dynasty Era (1984-1993)

Transitioning from Dynasty to Rebuilding:


After winning four consecutive Stanley Cup championships, the Islanders faced significant changes in their roster and coaching staff. Aging stars retired or moved to other teams, and the team had to rebuild and redefine its identity.


The departure of key players like Mike Bossy and Bryan Trottier presented a significant challenge, as they had been instrumental in the team's success. The Islanders had to find new leaders and young talent to carry the torch and establish a new era for the franchise.

The Departure of Key Players and Transitioning Leadership:


In the post-dynasty era, the Islanders saw the departure of several key players who had been integral to their success. Besides Bossy and Trottier, Denis Potvin retired in 1988, marking the end of an era for the Islanders.


With the departure of these iconic figures, new leaders emerged to guide the team. Pat LaFontaine, drafted in 1983, quickly became a cornerstone player, showcasing his offensive prowess and providing hope for the future. Alongside LaFontaine, players like Brent Sutter, Ken Morrow, and Patrick Flatley stepped up to assume leadership roles and contribute to the team's success.

Return to the Stanley Cup Final in 1984:


In the 1983-1984 season, the Islanders experienced a resurgence, returning to the Stanley Cup Final after the end of their dynasty. Under the leadership of head coach Al Arbour, the team showcased their resilience and determination.


Although they ultimately fell short, losing to the Edmonton Oilers, the Islanders' return to the Final demonstrated their ability to compete at a high level even after the departure of key players. This deep playoff run provided valuable experience for the younger players and gave fans a glimpse of hope for future success.

The Pat LaFontaine Era:


During the post-dynasty era, Pat LaFontaine emerged as the face of the franchise and a dominant force on the ice. LaFontaine's exceptional skill and offensive talent made him a fan favorite and a key Islander player.


LaFontaine achieved remarkable individual success, including multiple All-Star appearances and high-scoring seasons. His contributions to the team were crucial in keeping the Islanders competitive and maintaining their relevance in the league.


Sources:

  1. NHL.com. (n.d.). New York Islanders. Retrieved from https://www.nhl.com/islanders/

  2. Diamond, D. (2020, May 15). Revisiting the 1983-84 New York Islanders. Retrieved from https://thehockeywriters.com/new-york-islanders-1983-84-season/

  3. Fischler, S. (2019, September 9). The 10 Best Islanders Of The Post-Dynasty Era. Retrieved from https://thehockeywriters.com/best-new-york-islanders-post-dynasty/

The Turbulent Years (1994-2000)

Ownership Changes and Instability:


1. Ownership Changes and Instability:

The Islanders' turbulent years were characterized by frequent changes in ownership, which profoundly impacted the franchise's stability and direction. After a period of relative strength under John Pickett, the team underwent ownership transitions that brought uncertainty and financial challenges.


In 1997, Sanjay Kumar and Howard Milstein assumed ownership, but their tenure was short-lived, and the team changed hands again. Ownership instability affected the team's ability to make long-term plans and investments, creating a turbulent environment for the players and the organization.

Coaching Changes and Struggles on the Ice:


The Islanders experienced coaching instability during the turbulent years, with frequent changes behind the bench. The team needed help finding consistency and developing a winning culture, leading to several disappointing seasons.


Coaches such as Mike Milbury, Rick Bowness, and Butch Goring tried to guide the team through challenging times. Still, the constant turnover hindered the Islanders' ability to establish a stable coaching philosophy and build momentum.

Arena Issues and Relocation Rumors:


The Islanders faced arena-related challenges and persistent rumors of potential relocation during this period. The team encountered difficulties with its home arena, the Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum, which required renovations and updates to meet modern NHL standards.


Discussions surrounding a new arena and potential relocation intensified as the Islanders sought a more suitable long-term home. Various proposals and rumors circulated, including the possibility of the team moving to different locations, which added further uncertainty and anxiety for fans and the organization.

Return to the Playoffs in 1998:


Amidst the turbulence, the Islanders broke their playoff drought and returned to postseason action in the 1997-1998 season. Coached by Rick Bowness, the team showcased resilience and determination, securing a playoff berth.

Although they were eliminated in the first round, the Islanders' playoff appearance provided a glimmer of hope and demonstrated their ability to compete at a higher level. It also signaled a potential turning point for the franchise as it sought to regain stability and rebuild.


Sources:

  1. NHL.com. (n.d.). New York Islanders. Retrieved from https://www.nhl.com/islanders/

  2. Vacchiano, R. (2011, July 29). Islanders of '90s a study in frustration. Retrieved from https://www.newsday.com/sports/hockey/islanders/islanders-of-90s-a-study-in-frustration-1.3075276

  3. Eskenazi, G. (1997, June 21). Islanders' New Era: Milstein and Kumar Agree to Buy Team. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/1997/06/21/sports/hockey-islanders-new-era-milstein-kumar-agree-buy-team.html

The Millennial Years (2001-2019)

New Ownership and Stability:


The millennial years have brought a new sense of stability to the Islanders as new ownership took charge. In 2000, Charles Wang, a prominent businessman, purchased the team, aiming to revitalize the franchise and provide long-term stability.


Under Wang's ownership, the Islanders made significant investments in the team, including player acquisitions and facility improvements. This injection of stability and resources laid the groundwork for the team's subsequent successes.

Playoff Appearances and Playoff Successes:


The Islanders experienced a resurgence during the millennial years, returning to the playoffs and achieving notable successes. In the 2001-2002 season, under the guidance of head coach Peter Laviolette, the team secured a playoff berth, marking their first postseason appearance since 1994.


Subsequently, the Islanders qualified for the playoffs in multiple seasons, creating excitement among the fanbase. Although they faced early exits in some instances, the team's playoff appearances demonstrated their competitiveness and progress in reestablishing themselves as a playoff-contending team.

Key Players and the Rise of John Tavares:


During the millennial years, we witnessed the emergence of key players who became the foundation of the Islanders' success. Notably, John Tavares, the first overall draft pick in 2009, quickly made an impact and solidified himself as a franchise player.


Tavares' exceptional skill, leadership, and offensive prowess made him the face of the franchise during this era. His consistent performances and ability to produce points led the Islanders to significant victories and helped raise the team's profile in the league.

Arena Relocation and Return to Long Island:


During the millennial years, the Islanders faced challenges regarding their arena situation. After playing home games at the Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum for decades, the team briefly relocated to the Barclays Center in Brooklyn in 2015.


However, the Barclays Center's configuration for basketball made it less suitable for hockey, leading to concerns over the ice quality and the overall game experience. In 2018, the Islanders announced their return to their spiritual home, the renovated Nassau Coliseum, as they prepared to construct a new arena on Long Island.


Sources:

  1. NHL.com. (n.d.). New York Islanders. Retrieved from https://www.nhl.com/islanders/

  2. Rosen, D. (2016, February 29). Islanders' Barclays Center relocation off to a successful start. Retrieved from https://www.nhl.com/news/islanders-barclays-center-relocation-off-to-successful-start/c-279359810

  3. Gross, A. (2018, December 21). Islanders return to Nassau Coliseum, an arena reborn. Retrieved from https://www.newsday.com/sports/hockey/islanders/islanders-nassau-coliseum-1.24833329

Recent Years and Future Outlook (2020-2023)

Coaching and Front Office Changes:


The Islanders have witnessed significant changes in coaching and front-office personnel in recent years. A highly respected and accomplished coach, Barry Trotz was hired as the head coach in 2018. Trotz's arrival brought stability, structure, and a winning culture to the team.


Under the leadership of general manager Lou Lamoriello, the Islanders' front office transformed, focusing on building a competitive roster and fostering a winning environment. Lamoriello's vast experience and strategic approach have played a crucial role in the team's success.

The Islanders' Return to Stanley Cup Contention:


The Islanders experienced a resurgence in their on-ice performance, emerging as a formidable team in recent years. Under the guidance of Trotz, the team's defensive play improved significantly, making them one of the stingiest teams in the league.


In the 2019-2020 season, the Islanders reached the Eastern Conference Final, falling just short of a Stanley Cup Final appearance. The team's disciplined defensive style and timely scoring showcased their ability to compete with the league's elite.

Notable Players and Team Identity:


The Islanders' recent success can be attributed to the collective efforts of key players who have embraced the team's identity. Goaltender Semyon Varlamov has been a standout performer, providing consistent and exceptional goaltending, while Mathew Barzal has emerged as a dynamic offensive talent, bringing speed and skill to the team.


A strong emphasis on defense, disciplined play, and a relentless work ethic characterizes the Islanders' team identity. Players like Captain Anders Lee, Brock Nelson, and Ryan Pulock have exemplified these values, contributing to the team's recent accomplishments.

Prospects for the Future:


Looking ahead, the future appears bright for the New York Islanders. The team has developed a strong foundation and established a winning culture under the leadership of Trotz and Lamoriello. Their commitment to team defense and disciplined play has proven successful and sets a solid framework for sustained success.


Additionally, the Islanders boast a promising pipeline of young talent in their prospect pool. Players such as Oliver Wahlstrom, Noah Dobson, and Ilya Sorokin represent the next wave of talent, contributing to the team's continued competitiveness in the coming years.


Sources:

  1. NHL.com. (n.d.). New York Islanders. Retrieved from https://www.nhl.com/islanders/

  2. Masisak, C. (2020, September 18). Islanders' season ends with Eastern Conference Final loss to Lightning. Retrieved from https://theathletic.com/2067755/2020/09/17/islanders-season-ends-with-eastern-conference-final-loss-to-lightning/

  3. Morreale, M. (2021, April 21). Islanders prospect report: Wahlstrom among NHL-ready group. Retrieved from https://www.nhl.com/news/new-york-islanders-prospect-report-april-21-2021/c-323460110

Conclusion


The history of the New York Islanders is a testament to the franchise's resilience, determination, and passion. From their early years, through their dynastic success, and amidst turbulent periods, the Islanders have always found a way to rise. The team's impact on the sport, the community, and the dedicated fanbase is undeniable.


Looking ahead, the Islanders are poised to continue their upward trajectory. With a strong foundation, a winning culture, and a bright future, the team is primed for sustained success on the ice. The New York Islanders remain a proud franchise with a storied history, leaving an enduring legacy in hockey.


Sources:

  1. NHL.com. (n.d.). New York Islanders. Retrieved from https://www.nhl.com/islanders/

  2. Parrillo, R. (2017, January 27). The Isles' legacy began with a comeback. Retrieved from https://www.newsday.com/sports/hockey/islanders/islanders-legacy-1.12941333

  3. Saraceno, J. (2020, November 25). 'Let's keep it going': Islanders new deal to keep them in Nassau Coliseum. Retrieved from https://www.newsday.com/sports/hockey/islanders/nassau-coliseum-islanders-deal-1.50050360

FAQs

What are some fun facts about the New York Islanders?

Sure! Here are some fun facts about the New York Islanders: Dynasty Years: The New York Islanders made history by winning four consecutive Stanley Cup championships from 1980 to 1983. They are one of only four teams in NHL history to accomplish this feat. Unbreakable Record: During the 1981-1982 season, the Islanders won 15 consecutive playoff games, still the longest in NHL history. Rookie Sensation: In the 1978-1979 season, Mike Bossy had a great rookie campaign, scoring 53 goals. His outstanding performance earned him the Calder Memorial Trophy as the NHL's Rookie of the Year. Goalie Magic: Billy Smith, the Islanders' goaltender during their dynasty years, was known for his clutch performances and fierce competitiveness. He became the first goalie in NHL history to be awarded the Conn Smythe Trophy as the most valuable player in the playoffs in 1983. Potvin's Trophies: Denis Potvin, one of the greatest defensemen in NHL history, won the Norris Trophy as the league's top defenseman three times in his career (1976, 1978, and 1979). Captain Courageous: Bryan Trottier was the Islanders' captain during their dynasty years. He was a key leader on and off the ice, contributing significantly to the team's success. Trottier won the Hart Trophy (NHL MVP) and the Art Ross Trophy (scoring champion) in the 1978-1979 season. Retired Numbers: The New York Islanders have retired the numbers of some of their most iconic players. These include Denis Potvin (#5), Bryan Trottier (#19), Mike Bossy (#22), Clark Gillies (#9), and Billy Smith (#31). Longest Serving Coach: Al Arbour, the Islanders' legendary head coach, spent 1,500 games behind the team's bench. He guided the Islanders to their four Stanley Cup championships and is among the most respected coaches in NHL history. All-Star Representation: Over the years, the New York Islanders have had numerous players represent the team at the NHL All-Star Game, including notable names like John Tavares, Pat LaFontaine, and Denis Potvin. Return to Long Island: After a stint in Brooklyn, the Islanders returned to their original home, playing home games at the renovated Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum before moving to the new UBS Arena in Belmont Park. These fun facts highlight some of the remarkable achievements and notable moments in the history of the New York Islanders, showcasing the team's rich legacy in the NHL.

When did NY Islanders come into existence?

The New York Islanders came into existence in 1972. They were established as one of the National Hockey League's (NHL) expansion teams, along with the Atlanta Flames, as part of the league's initiative to expand its reach and tap into new markets. The Islanders were awarded to a consortium by Roy Boe, who saw an opportunity to bring NHL hockey to Long Island, New York. Since their inception, the Islanders have become an integral part of the New York sports landscape, captivating fans with their exciting brand of hockey.

Who owns New York Islanders?

As of my knowledge cutoff in September 2021, Jon Ledecky and Scott Malkin own the New York Islanders. They acquired the majority team ownership in 2016, succeeding Charles Wang, who had been the franchise's principal owner since 2004. Ledecky and Malkin are committed to the long-term success of the Islanders and have played an active role in shaping the team's direction both on and off the ice. However, please note that ownership information can change, and it's always advisable to refer to the most up-to-date and reliable sources for the latest information on team ownership.

Gary J. Broome

Gary J. Broome is a newbie sports blogger passionate about all things sports-related. While he may be new to sports blogging, he is eager to learn and grow as a commentator on the latest sports news and trends. Gary is excited to share his insights and opinions with his readers and strives to create engaging content that will keep fans coming back for more. He is particularly interested in football and basketball and constantly researches the latest games, players, and teams to provide his readers with up-to-date information and analysis. Despite being a newcomer to sports blogging, Gary's enthusiasm and dedication make him a promising voice in sports journalism. 

BACK TO TOP